Vintage baseball nostalgia meets modern collecting.
We Buy and Consign Collections
Cleaning out a collection, settling an estate, or ready to cash in a closet full of cardboard? Send us a few photos. We will make you a fair, no-pressure offer to buy it outright, or consign it and we will sell it for you.
Get a Free QuoteWelcome to the Time Machine.
Join the Guild. Help build a legendary repository of history.
Every checklist here is built by hand, card by card, by collectors like you, read straight off the cards we own. Come collect. Come chase the sets you love.
Help build the checklists →We Buy and Consign Collections
Cleaning out a collection, settling an estate, or ready to cash in a closet full of cardboard? Send us a few photos and we’ll make you a fair, no-pressure offer.
Sellers We Stand Behind
Stores we actually buy from. Two of these are affiliate links, so MTM may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our own store is not affiliate tagged, because that is not how any of this should work.
Mortythemaker
99.9% positive · 3.6K sold
Our own store. Vintage singles, graded cards and weekly auctions.
Visit the store →
bonkers-cards
100% positive · 882 sold
Top Rated Seller with a deep vintage and high-end run.
Visit the store →
NoDoubterTC
99.8% positive · 15K sold
Huge everyday inventory of vintage singles and set fillers.
Visit the store →
Join the conversation.
Pickups, drops, market chatter, the occasional bad joke. Drop your binder in the chat — we'll trade notes.
This week on Substack.
Fresh from the weekly newsletter — collecting hacks, market reads, and the occasional rabbit hole.